Table of Contents
- The headline numbers
- The big four went home
- When the name is worth more than the car
- Scoring my own homework
- Sunday, where the rest of us shop
- The motorcycles
- What it means if you are buying or selling
- Next up
Two weeks ago I picked out the lots to watch at Iconic Auctioneers' sale at the NEC Classic Motor Show, its biggest ever, with more than 600 cars and bikes and over £16m of estimates. The hammer has now come down on all of it, and the weekend split very neatly in two.
The cars with a famous name attached sold, and most of them sold well. The very expensive cars that had to stand on their own mostly did not.
All the figures below come from Iconic's own lot pages for the Iconic Sale, the Classic Sale and the motorcycle sale, as they stood on Monday afternoon. Iconic publishes a "sold for" price that is the hammer price plus its 12.5% buyer's premium (VAT on the premium comes on top), so that is what I quote. Estimates are hammer figures, so where I compare a result with its estimate I take the premium back off first. Eighteen cars were sold for "an undisclosed sum", and they count as sold but add nothing to the totals. I also could not get at the prices for 16 of Sunday's later lots before writing, so the Sunday total is a little light.
The headline numbers
Iconic listed 377 lots across Saturday's Iconic Sale and Sunday's Classic Sale. Six were withdrawn, so 371 crossed the block, and 306 of them sold. A handful of Sunday's lots were children's cars, pedal cars among them, but they are a rounding error. That is a sell-through of 82%, against the 83% Iconic reported for last year's NEC sale.
| Saturday: Iconic Sale | Sunday: Classic Sale | Both days | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Lots offered | 158 | 213 | 371 |
| Sold | 123 | 183 | 306 |
| Sell-through | 78% | 86% | 82% |
| Sold with a published price | 114 | 157 | 271 |
| Published total | £8,958,609 | £2,736,929 | £11,695,538 |
| Middle price | £45,844 | £13,725 | £23,063 |
So about three pounds in every four changed hands on Saturday, and the ten dearest cars that day made £3.35m between them. Sunday sold a higher share of what it offered, at much lower prices, which is exactly what you would expect of the two catalogues.
The money at the top tells a different story from the sell-through, though. The cars that went home on Saturday are still for sale through Iconic, and their "buy it now" prices add up to £3.64m. Three cars account for £1.73m of that.
The big four went home
Six of the eight lots I picked out before the sale were the expensive ones. Here is what happened to them.
| Lot | Estimate | Result |
|---|---|---|
| 1983 Lamborghini Countach LP5000 S | From £700,000 | Not sold |
| 1970 Aston Martin DB6 Mk2 Volante | £450,000 to £550,000 | Not sold |
| 1980 BMW M1 | £400,000 to £500,000 | Not sold |
| 2004 Mercedes-Benz CLK DTM AMG, ex-Jenson Button | £400,000 to £500,000 | £410,625 (hammer £365,000) |
| 1986 Porsche 911 Turbo SE Flachbau, ex-Ron Dennis | £350,000 to £400,000 | £382,500 (hammer £340,000) |
| 1966 Honda RC173, ex-Mike Hailwood | £750,000 to £950,000 | Not sold |
The Countach, the Volante and the M1 are all now on Iconic's site at £747,500, £517,500 and £460,000 respectively. The Volante came from the collection of Iconic's own founder, Nick Whale, so even the house could not find a buyer at its price for its own car.
The two that did sell both went below their low estimates. Jenson Button's CLK DTM was £35,000 short at the hammer and Ron Dennis's Flachbau £10,000 short. Both are about as good a story as a modern classic can have, and still nobody would pay the guide.
The day's top price was not on my list at all. A delivery-mileage 2016 Porsche 911 R made £556,667, ahead of the CLK and of a car that rather stole the show.
| Car | Sold for | |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | 2016 Porsche 911 R, delivery mileage | £556,667 |
| 2 | 2004 Mercedes-Benz CLK DTM AMG, ex-Jenson Button | £410,625 |
| 3 | 1996 Ferrari F355 GTS, delivered new to Jeremy Clarkson | £405,000 |
| 4 | 1986 Porsche 911 Turbo SE Flachbau, ex-Ron Dennis | £382,500 |
| 5 | 1988 Aston Martin V8 Vantage Volante "Prince of Wales" | £365,625 |
| 6 | 1973 Ferrari Dino 246 GTS | £337,500 |
| 7 | 2008 Lamborghini Murciélago LP640-4 | £292,500 |
| 8 | 1991 Lamborghini Diablo 5.7 | £202,500 |
| 8 | 1990 BMW M3 (E30) Sport Evolution | £202,500 |
| 10 | 2001 Nissan Skyline GT-R (R34) V-Spec, 7,288 miles | £191,250 |
When the name is worth more than the car
Here is the other half of the weekend. Jeremy Clarkson's Ferrari F355 GTS, which he ordered new in 1996, sold for £405,000, a hammer price of £360,000. Motoring Research reports that Iconic had guided it at £200,000 to £250,000. Earlier the same day a manual F355 Spider with no famous owner made £110,250.
Noel Gallagher's 1978 Rolls-Royce Silver Shadow II was estimated at £25,000 to £30,000. It made £65,250, a hammer price of £58,000, which is about double the top estimate. The Reliant Supervan from Only Fools and Horses was not far behind on Sunday: £30,000 to £40,000 estimated, £70,875 paid (hammer £63,000), and it was the most expensive car in the Classic Sale by more than £10,000. It beat a Ferrari 365 GT4 2+2 by nearly seventeen grand.
Clarkson's three Grand Tour cars, all sold without reserve, made:
- 1982 Lancia Montecarlo Spider, from One for the Road: £69,188
- 1978 Lincoln Continental Mark V, from Lochdown: £46,125
- 1983 Alfa Romeo GTV6, from Well Aged Scotch: £45,000
The GTV6 is the neatest comparison, because there was another one in the same sale. It made £39,375. So being Clarkson's was worth about £5,600 on an Alfa, and something nearer £300,000 on a Ferrari. The Lancia I will come to.
Not every name worked that hard. Chris Harris's old Jaguar XKR, Big Red, made £18,000, a hammer of £16,000 and bang on its low estimate. The two cars from Nick Mason's Ten Tenths Collection, a V12 E-type roadster and a 1928 Morgan three-wheeler, made £67,500 and £34,875. Harry Metcalfe's Jaguar XE Project 8 made £158,625.
Scoring my own homework
I made two calls before the sale.
One: Clarkson's Lancia would be the clearest test of what a name is worth, because it had gone backwards as a Montecarlo and anything above the price of a tidy standard car would be the Clarkson premium. It made £69,188 with no reserve. That is more than either of his other two cars, more than the best Escort RS Cosworth made on Sunday, and more than Gallagher's Rolls. For a mid-engined Lancia wearing a Delta's grille and a Ferrari's tail lights, nearly all of that is Clarkson. I will call that one right.
Two: the Reliant would get to its £30,000 to £40,000 estimate, because British buyers are not rational about Only Fools and Horses. It got to £63,000 at the hammer. I said that if it fell short, the Goodwood mood had reached the cheap seats. It did not fall short. It fell about £23,000 long.
What I did not see coming was the other side of it. I thought the names were the risky part of the catalogue and the big metal was the safe part. It was the other way round.
Sunday, where the rest of us shop
The Classic Sale is the one most readers will actually bid at, and it was in good health. It sold 86% of what it offered, and 104 of the 157 of the cars with a published price went for under £20,000.
The cheapest car of the weekend was a 2000 Ford Mondeo ST24 at £1,575. A Rover Streetwise made £1,800. An MGB GT and a Mazda Eunos Roadster made £2,925 each, and a 1962 Volvo Amazon two-door went for £3,150. At the other end, a 1996 Escort RS Cosworth made £60,188 and a 1974 Ferrari 365 GT4 2+2 with a manual gearbox £54,000.
Two Lotus Esprits came out of long storage. The Signal Red Series 1 showing 25,894 miles made £32,625 (hammer £29,000, inside its £25,000 to £30,000 estimate). The Series 3, believed to be one of four in Altair Green, made £18,000, a hammer of £16,000 that beat its top estimate by a thousand pounds.
Low mileage was worth a lot all weekend. On Saturday a 1972 Escort 1300 XL with 126 miles on it made £30,938, a nine-mile Focus RS Red Edition £49,500 and the 47-mile Civic Type R wearing plaque number R-00001 £42,188. A delivery-mileage Rover Mini Cooper made £24,750, which is a lot of money for a Mini that has never been anywhere.
The motorcycles
The Iconic Motorcycle Sale ran alongside the Classic Sale from 10.30am on Sunday, with 258 lots including a fair bit of memorabilia. One was withdrawn, and Iconic marks 204 of the rest as sold, which is about four in five.
The star did not sell. Mike Hailwood's 1966 Honda RC173, the works 350 that won him the world title, was estimated at £750,000 to £950,000 and is now listed at £885,000 to buy. Joey Dunlop's TT-winning Honda SP-1 went home too, and is listed at £94,400 against an £80,000 to £100,000 estimate.
Aleix Espargaró's 2020 Aprilia RS-GP, sold by the man himself with his leathers and helmet, did find a buyer, at £172,500. Even with the premium on top, that is short of its £200,000 to £300,000 estimate. So the bikes told the same story as the cars: the sale went fine, and the trophy lots could not get to their numbers.
What it means if you are buying or selling
Put this next to the Goodwood Revival in September and the pattern holds. Buyers are turning up and buying, and the share of cars that sell is healthy. What they will not do is pay last year's money for a big car just because it is rare and well documented. The Countach, the Volante, the M1 and Hailwood's Honda all had stories most cars would kill for, and none of them found a bidder at the vendor's number.
The exception is a story the room already loves. Clarkson's Ferrari, Gallagher's Rolls and Del Boy's van all went well past their top estimates, the Rolls to nearly double. The people who bought them were not really buying a car.
If you are selling something good but not famous, set the reserve at what comparable cars have actually made this year. The CLK and the Flachbau both sold, just under their low estimates, and their owners have the money. The Countach's owner has a "buy it now" page.
If you are buying, the cars that went home are still listed for sale through Iconic, so the conversation is not over. The Sunday sale is the place to start, though: more than four lots in five sold, and half of those with a published price made less than £14,000.
Next up
The season carries on indoors. Charterhouse sells in Sherborne on Thursday 19 November, Dore & Rees has its collectors' cars sale on Saturday the 21st, and Historics is at Mercedes-Benz World, Brooklands, on Saturday the 28th. Iconic itself is back in the new year, at Race Retro on Saturday 20 February and at the NEC again for the Classic Car & Restoration Show sale on 20 and 21 March. Everything else is on our auction calendar, and if you want to know how bidding, premiums and post-sale deals work before you go, our guide to how classic car auctions work covers it.
Welcome aboard. A confirmation is on its way to your inbox.